The secret of a successful company is a great team…

If there ever is a problem, you need to be able to talk to a broker that is near to you and can give advice that puts your needs first, not those of the insurance company. As insurance brokers it is our job to represent you and act on your behalf to help settle issues, such as claims and coverage.
We’re all so close…it’s almost like we’re family! Now you know a little about us. Give us a call and we can learn about you and how we can get you the coverage you need.

Our Team

We have been in business since 1900, and during that time we have seen the insurance industry evolve into a complex and demanding industry. With 12 experienced brokers on staff, we are here to help meet the challenges that you, the insured, encounter in today’s insurance world.

If you would like a quote for your home, auto or business place, please contact us using the options that works best for you – call, email.

Alexandra McGoey

Personal Lines Account Manager

Alex has been working in the insurance industry since 2013; first as an auto claims adjuster and then in 2015 she transitioned into the broker role here in Tottenham. She spent her childhood in Tottenham and recently moved back to town within the last couple years.

She enjoys spending time in nature with friends and family, photography and playing the drums.


Ext. 106

Jennifer Carter

Personal Lines Account Manager

Jennifer has been in the insurance industry for two decades and has worked as an agent for an insurance company for 10 years before becoming a broker.
Jennifer is a born & bred ‘city girl’ but has since made the change from skyscrapers to farm fields 4 years ago when she made the move to Tottenham. In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her children.

Jennifer is an avid fan of the UFC, and is a big supporter of Conor McGregor & Stephen Thompson & Jon Jones


Ext. 115

Emily Purchase

Personal Lines Account Manager

Emily has worked in the insurance industry for over 10 years. She joined the McGoey team in February 2011, starting out with data entry and quickly working her way up to a broker. She takes a customer-focused approach when working with her clients and understands the value in providing a cost-effective solution to their needs.

In her free time, she enjoys spending time with her 2 children, cooking, reading and relaxing with a glass of wine with her friends.


Ext. 118

Nikki Mann

Personal Lines Account Manager

Nikki has been working in the office since 1994, and has worked out of the Alliston Office for the last 2 years. In her free time, she loves spending time outdoors with her two kids and the revolving door of adopted dogs she takes care of.

We hear Nikki is a pretty good Ball Hockey Player, competing at the Worlds last year in Banff; so if I were you…. I would watch out if she has a hockey stick in her hands.


Ext. 214

Adam Rosato

Personal Lines Account Manager

Adam has been working in the office since 2006, and has worked out of the Alliston Office for the last 3 years. In his free time, Adam loves playing hockey and spending time with his wife and 2 kids. Adam is also an avid volunteer for TNT Minor Hockey Association.


Ext. 203

Tracy Gravelle

General Manager

Tracy has been working in the insurance industry since 2005 and joined the McGoey commercial team in December 2012. She was appointed General Manager in July of 2015 she keeps Tod and Mike in control and really enjoys it!

Tracy grew up in Keenansville and has never been far from this small town that is growing! She enjoys traveling with her husband and spending her downtime in her beautiful backyard.


Ext. 109

Judy Parkes


Born and raised in Sault Ste Marie, Ontario, Judy’s first big move was to Toronto, where she lived and worked in the heart of downtown. Several years later, another move took her to a small village in Oxfordshire, England. On her return to Canada with her husband, Tottenham was the perfect compromise, close to the big city but will a small town feel.

Along with the move to the Ontario countryside, Judy gave up her career in IT and enjoys working in a local office, being close enough to home to avoid the commute, and to be able to have lunch at home with her dog, Whiskey.


Ext. 120

Mike McGoey

Vice President

Mike started at the office in 1985 and takes great joy in the fact that he was able to start his career working with his father and now gets to work with his daughter. Mike works in the Commercial Dept specializing on larger Accounts.

Born and raised in Tottenham he spends his free time through various hobbies such as golfing, playing the drums, metal detecting and watercolor painting; in fact you can see some of his artwork throughout the office.


Ext. 113

Heather Vigneault

Stephanie Mazzaferro

Nicole O'Callaghan

Melanie Green

Amanda Dykeman

On MAT Leave

Maria Teter

Cheryl Bulpit-Hickman

Sheri Thompson

Tod McGoey

Art Needles

Our Insurance Partners