Brokers Who Care

Get a Quote
Auto Insurance
Property Insurance
Motorcycle Icon Car Icon Trailer Icon

The Best Coverage For The Best Price

Getting the right product for the best price can be a daunting task. McGoey Insurance is here to help you get the automobile policy that is best suited to you including proper deductibles, accident benefits, liability and collision coverage.

Get a Direct Online Quote
Home Icon Commercial Icon Farm Icon

The Best Coverage For The Best Price

Home insurance is becoming increasingly harder to maintain as insurances companies are suffering from larger claims with water damage, oil spills and other natural disasters. Every home is unique, so let McGoey Insurance help you get the right evaluation and coverage on your property and advise you on your requirements for woodstoves, oil tanks, swimming pools etc.

Get a Direct Online Quote

Welcome to McGoey Brothers Insurance

Proudly In Business Since 1900

At McGoey Insurance, we have been part of the community for over 115 years providing home, auto, farm and commercial insurance. Our team of friendly and experienced staff are all local residents familiar with the area and have an understanding of your insurance needs.

Personal service has always been our credo, and McGoey Insurance can make a difference on how you view the insurance world. Our commitment is to provide you with the best insurance value and service available and to help you find the product that suits your lifestyle.

Tottenham train station in the past

Latest News

Intact’s Water Damage Prevention PDF
Tips to Reduce Risk of Basement Flooding
Tips to Protect Your Home
IBAO Auto Reform Videos and Blogs

Our Insurance Partners

  • Chieftan
  • Echelon
  • Intact
  • Travelers
  • Wawanesa
  • Heartland Farmers Mutual
  • Western Assurance

McGoey Brothers Insurance
10 Mill Street East, PO Box 40
Tottenham, Ontario L0G 1W0

Tel: 905 936 3441
Fax: 905 936 3971

Store Hours Mon - Fri: 8:00 am to 5:00 pm