The Secret to a Successful Business? A Great Team.
When a problem arises, you deserve a broker who’s nearby and ready to put your needs first—not the insurance company’s. As your dedicated insurance brokers, we’re here to represent you and work on your behalf, whether it’s helping with claims, coverage, or any other issues that come your way.
We’re a close-knit team, almost like family—and we treat our clients the same way. Now that you know a bit about us, why not give us a call? We’d love to learn more about you and how we can provide the perfect coverage to keep your business running smoothly.
Our Team
We have been in business since 1900, and during that time we have seen the insurance industry evolve into a complex and demanding industry. With 12 experienced brokers on staff, we are here to help meet the challenges that you, the insured, encounter in today’s insurance world.
If you would like a quote for your home, auto or business place, please contact us using the options that works best for you – call, email.
Alexandra McGoey
Personal Lines Account ManagerAlex, an insurance broker since 2015, returned to her hometown, Tottenham. She loves nature, photography, and playing the drums.
Jennifer Carter
Personal Lines Account ManagerJennifer, a broker with 20+ years in insurance, left city life for Tottenham. She loves UFC and enjoys spending time with her kids.
Emily Purchase
Personal Lines Account ManagerEmily, in insurance for 10+ years, joined McGoey in 2011. A client-focused broker, she enjoys her kids, cooking, reading, and wine.
Nikki Mann
Personal Lines Account ManagerNikki, with McGoey since 1994, now in Alliston, loves the outdoors, her kids, dogs, and playing ball hockey—she competed at Worlds!
Adam Rosatto
Personal Lines Account ManagerAdam, with McGoey since 2006, now in Alliston. He loves hockey, spending time with his wife and kids, and volunteering for TNT Minor Hockey.
Tracey Gavelle
General ManagerTracy, in insurance since 2005, joined McGoey in 2012 and became GM in 2015. She enjoys traveling and relaxing in her beautiful backyard.
Judy Parkes
AdministrativeJudy, from Sault Ste Marie, lived in Toronto, before settling in Tottenham. She enjoys working close to home and being with her dog, Whiskey
Mike McGoey
Vice PresidentMike, with the office since 1985, started his career with his father and now works with his daughter. He enjoys golfing, drumming, painting.
Heather Vigneault
Stephanie Mazzaferro
Nicole O’Callaghan
Melanie Green
Amanda Dykeman
On MAT leave
Maria Teter
Cheryl Bulpit-Hickman
Sheri Thompson
Lora Sinkler- Lake
Tod McGoey
Our Partners
Get a personalized insurance quote from
our McGoey Team Today!